Radio Review

This course has subjected me to BBC Radio 3. I need to call ChildLine:
The Essay
BBC Radio 3
11 to 11.15 pm.

AS PART of his continued series The Essay, Hugh Cunningham studies the reasonably modern social preoccupation with the balance between work and leisure time.

Britain, as Cunningham describes, has always been a society orientated around the need for hard work. If those in the 19th century knew how much time and effort we spend debating how to use our leisure time, it would have provoked astonishment. The general consensus was a man perfects himself through hard work, the most noble of things.

The rise of Marxism provided a new strategy. He believed that our ability to apply ourselves to work was what distinguished ourselves from animals but also alienated man from his true nature.

An utopic vision was born by three factory owners called Carlisle, Ruskin and Morris, who are recognised as some of the founding fathers of the labour movement. They believed work could be at once individually fulfilling and socially necessary.

Unfortunately, this has never been realised and, although our working lives can now be characterised as less physical, it can be as monotonous and is accompanied by more pressure.

We have now, Cunningham says, become saturated with the idea of how our work defines our identity and by impinges on our family lives. This, at least, is a sign of progress.

The Ocean- What Lies Beneath
BBC Radio 4
9 – 9.30pm.

Man may have walked on the moon and worked out a way to communicate with each other from every corner of the earth in which we populate so comprehensively, but one aspect of our world remains largely unknown – the ocean.

BBC Radio 4′s programme What Lies Beneath, presented by Gabriel Walker, argued that we may be on the verge of a golden age of discovery as we begin to explore and harvest coral reefs for the dense chemical compounds which its animals naturally produce as a means of survival.

“We have spent centuries exploring the land,” said scientist Leon Sann. “This is the century of the sea.”

In an age where we are faced with increasingly damaging and destructive diseases – AIDS, cancer, superbugs and Alzheimer’s disease – we are ignoring a vast resource of potential answers, an “immeasurable chemical factory.”

Talking about the chemicals secreted from sea anemones found in the coral reef, scientist William Fenickle said: “These are compounds that have evolved over millions of years, and are so much more developed than anything we can possibly hope to make in a lab. It is a nice idea that creatures that are protecting themselves can also be used to protect us.”

The show communicated how excited scientists are by the new information that could be discovered and cures to be developed. The show also voiced concerns that coral reef is already in particular danger from intensive tourism and irresponsible fishing.

“Its exploration for the purpose of exploitation,” said Walker.

History Will Be Kind To Me

The BBC’s treatment of history. 

picture-5

Edward Sorel. First Encounters: Josef Stalin and Winston Churchill, 1991

 

I assumed a horizontal position on the sofa the other night with my cat and a bottle of red and hopped the channels before settling on a show called World War Two Behind Closed Doors, a historical documentary about the intricate political wranglings that took place at five minutes to the midnight of the Second World War. 

With its late Sunday evening slot on BBC 2, World War Two Behind Closed Doors is bread and butter for the BBC, the kind of program they’ve been trading off for years. 

The usual criteria are present. Expensive dramatisations of real-life events are intercut with eyewitness interviews and a sombre voiceover. Both accessible and cerebral, investigative and informative. Proper television when ITV are offering Craziest Police Car Chases Ever 6 and Channel 4 have got I’m an Albino Prostitute With a Lizard Fetish and I Feel Picked on at Work.

After a little digging, it appears Behind Closed Doors is a big deal for the BBC. The series marks the departure of Laurence Rees, the BBC’s Creative Head of History and go-to man for documentaries. Over the last 12 years, Rees has been responsible for War of the Century, The Nazis: A Warning From History and Auschwitz. According to this article by Jasper Rees (apparently not a relation):

“It’s not going too far to state that much of what most viewers know about the war, they know because Rees has told them.”

The BBC laud themselves as being the best broadcaster in the world, and they may very well be. But how much are they taking this title, and with it their audience, for granted?

Underneath this veneer of respectability and substance, World War Two Behind Closed Doors is little more than a base character assassination of Josef Stalin. The vast majority of the hour-long program was not about the Second World War, not even really about the thawing of relationships between America and Russia that led to the Cold War. It was about Stalin being a ruthless, bloodthirsty, paranoid bastard, and not an awful lot else. 

Don’t get me wrong. I acknowledge it’s difficult to be even-handed with a guy like Uncle Joe. He was probably all those things and more. But as the program progressed its depiction of Stalin became increasingly Disneyfied.

Stalin as a panto-villain may be a good idea for the next controversial West End show, maybe something Damon Albarn can get involved in, but surely a statutory commitment to objectivity is still the basic foundation from which to build any sort of documentary, be it contemporaneous or historical?

To dismiss Stalin as this mad, power-hungry and bloodthirsty brute shrouded in an Iron Curtain is easy, unchallenging and about as investigative as Spot the Dog. Surely we’re better than this.

I asked my Dad what he thought and he said: 

“This is about as close to historical fact as you are going to get.” 

This may be true, but they were specific facts carefully chosen from the myriad of facts available to someone who wants to make a program such as this. 

Maybe Britain feels it has a privileged position when it comes to interpreting history. We did, after all, win two world wars. As Churchill said: 

“History will be kind to me for I intend to write it.”

One wonders how history would have been documented if the other side had won or if the Cold War had ignited. Would we now be watching programs by the Soviet Broadcasting Company about how Churchill, a bulbous, bourgeois capitalist, was the first to order the bombing of civilian areas in the war? 

Churchill did, after all, give the order to raze Dresden, the jewel of Europe. He ordered the firebombing of Tokyo knowing that it was mostly made of wood and would go up like a box of matches. He refused to evacuate Coventry after the intelligence services at Bletchley Park had broken the German code. 

Truman was the man who reacted with elation on hearing that the Atom bomb had caused far much more devastation and loss of human life in Hiroshima than indicated by the tests. He was soon working out where the next target would be. 

Tell you what, I’ll write to Laurence Rees with a suggestion for his next series.

Watching the American elections earlier on this year bought it home time and time again; rash, loud, arrogant patriotism is not something that comes naturally to Britain.

This is not to say this country is not patriotic. We are arrogantly patriotic, but in a quiet, knowing, sweep it under the table way. 

Even if we wanted it to, this won’t change so long as we are fed on a diet of historical documentaries that merely reinforces a message; Britain possesses the moral high-ground and everybody else are sly, stooping, unreasonable and underhand. 

Maybe the BBC have a better grasp of history and understand their audience far more intricately than I do. Therefore, they fulfill a far more complex role within our national consciousness than merely the trade of information and entertainment.

And maybe the holy grail of objectivity is just that; a fairy tale, helping us to sleep easy at night.

Blog at WordPress.com.
Theme: Esquire by Matthew Buchanan.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 1,140 other followers